Home improvement is all about weighing benefits, like time versus money or long-term value versus short-term needs. One debate that many homeowners encounter, specifically when exploring decking options, is whether to choose natural wood or composite materials. Before making an investment in either, it’s best to know the facts.

As a licensed contractor, this is the advice I share with my homeowners who are interested in a deck:

Cost

One of the many benefits of working with natural wood is its lower upfront cost. You can install a natural wood deck for less money than you’d spend on the alternative – a great incentive for taking the natural route.

Appearance

Wood is naturally beautiful, period. Although composite materials mimic real wood, there is no replacement for the look, feel and smell of real wood. For me, there’s also the appeal of working amidst sawdust. It’s one of my favorite smells!

Versatility

Wood can easily be transformed by sanding and applying a new coat of stain. Since composites are manufactured, the appearance isn’t easily (or cheaply) changed. Considering the speed at which styles change, this versatility allows you to keep your deck from looking outdated.

If you choose to expand your wood deck or add a shade structure, simply purchase the same wood species and your addition will look seamless. If you want to expand your composite deck, you’ll first need to make sure the shade of your original composite deck is still produced. At which point, you could be left with the choice to have your addition not match the rest of your deck or, worse, start over completely.

After Effects

Wood is a natural, renewable resource, and therefore, biodegradable. Wood decks store carbon throughout their lives, making for a much lower carbon footprint.

Unlike real wood, composites end up in landfills. Composite decking is typically made from a combination of different synthetic materials that are processed to give the appearance of wood. Considering decks are recreational, I feel responsible for choosing a source material that doesn’t just have minimal impact on nature, but will eventually return to it as compost.

While many people purchase a composite deck because they think it requires zero maintenance, that isn’t quite true. Any structure exposed to the elements will require some maintenance.

Already picked your decking material? Check out these tips for selecting a contractor.

Host, DIY Network’s Rescue Renovation, licensed contractor and 2009 Stud Finder winner. Kayleen also works extensively with Skills USA, a partnership of students, teachers and industry working together to develop a skilled workforce. Kayleen has done custom construction projects, including pergolas, decks and a house.